By Lucas Guaraldo
The record-breaking El Niño predicted for late 2026 is already here. Although the predicted major floods and heat waves may not have materialized yet, the effects of the phenomenon are already causing damage and threatening food security and the quality of life of traditional peoples and communities, especially in the Amazon.
In this biweekly edition, Um Grau e Meio interviews Patrícia Pinho, deputy director of science at IPAM and co-author of a report by the United Nations’ IPCC (Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change).
According to the researcher, even though the most extreme scenarios—such as severe storms and increased mortality—have not yet materialized, El Niño is already having significant social impacts. The effects primarily affect populations that depend directly on forests and native vegetation or that live in municipalities with limited capacity to respond to extreme weather events.
The solution, according to Patrícia, lies in developing public policies tailored to the specific characteristics of each region and in understanding the scale of the impacts: it is necessary to identify which damages are isolated incidents and which cause lasting changes in the living conditions of these communities.
What impacts of El Niño can already be observed, especially from a social perspective?
One of the characteristics of these ElNiñoyears is precisely the change in climate patterns. In the Northern Hemisphere, for example, there was a high concentration of heat waves, which continued even into the fall. In southeastern Brazil, we have also observed disproportionately heavy rainfall.
From a scientific perspective, there is great variability in how El Niño can manifest itself. But one thing is certain: whether they are intense heat waves, extreme droughts in the Amazon, or heavy rains, the socioeconomic impacts are significant.
The fact that some of the more extreme predictions have not yet materialized does not mean that these impacts cannot occur. El Niño is already underway, and we are still in a period where the phenomenon is intensifying, with effects that may manifest in different ways throughout the spring and summer of 2026–2027.
We have already observed climate destabilization, such as more widespread warming in the Central-West, North, and Northeast regions.
How does this scenario manifest itself in the Amazon? What impacts are Indigenous and traditional communities already facing?
It is important to consider both extreme events and those that develop gradually. Heat waves and severe droughts, for example, may develop gradually, but they cause profound damage to territories and become increasingly difficult to cope with as they intensify.
In the Amazon, we observe that people living in the region—especially Indigenous peoples and traditional communities—are already feeling the effects of these changes. The seasons are becoming increasingly erratic. Droughts, for example, are becoming not only more severe but also longer-lasting. At the same time, the intensity of flood impacts has also increased.
Over the past two decades, nearly 2 million people have been affected annually by climate-related disasters in the Amazon. This scenario was also observed during the 2015–2016 El Niño. Now, in light of the 2026–2027 event, we need to consider the possibility of new impacts.
Furthermore, the populations most affected live precisely in the most vulnerable municipalities. More than 60% of Indigenous people and more than 70% of the traditional population reside in municipalities where more than half the population was affected by disasters in the Amazon during this period. And there is an important issue: the experiences of these indigenous peoples and traditional communities are not always reflected in the statistics. Therefore, the impacts on income, health, nutrition, and living conditions may be even greater.
Agriculture and livestock farming are among the hardest-hit sectors. This means not only lost revenue and economic losses but also impacts on essential aspects such as food security, health, and nutrition. There is also a generational dimension: food insecurity can compromise children’s development.
These impacts also disrupt transportation and hinder access to education. To prevent children and adults from facing the most severe periods of drought, some families adapt their routines. This may mean, for example, reducing the amount of time children spend in school. As these events become increasingly frequent in the Amazon, such adaptations may jeopardize the continuity of education and exacerbate inequalities compared to other regions of the country.
And how have public authorities been addressing this issue?
Although Brazil has made progress on some public policies and in resuming its commitments under the Paris Agreement, we are still struggling to make headway on the response agenda. The response is highly uneven. In the most affected regions, such as the Amazon, there is still a lack of measures capable of mitigating the risks.
Public authorities, especially in smaller municipalities, have limited capacity to respond. And this is key to understanding why certain climate events turn into disasters: there is an exposed and highly vulnerable population, but institutional responses are insufficient or arrive too late.
The IPCC predicted that, starting in 2030, developing countries and emerging economies could lose between 6% and 9% of their Gross Domestic Product as a result of climate impacts. In the Amazon, this scenario has already materialized: in two decades, the region has lost more than 6% of its GDP due to disasters.
This should lead us to reflect on the point at which these losses become irreversible. Is it possible to restore a municipality that has lost a significant portion of its economic growth? Is it possible to put it back on a path toward income generation, security, and well-being? Over a 30-year horizon, this may no longer be feasible.
This is an important aspect of the loss and damage agenda: we need to understand when the impacts cease to be merely economic and begin to pose a lasting threat to the population, the economy, the way of life, and the culture of a region like the Amazon.
How can Amazonian communities prepare for these impacts?
In the Amazon, rivers are expected to reach lower levels, droughts are expected to intensify, and the number of wildfires is expected to increase due to high temperatures and heat waves. As I mentioned, these impacts affect different aspects of people’s livelihoods and health.
Rivers are the lifelines that connect people to their lands. They are the means by which resources are extracted and produce is transported out of the region, as well as the way goods enter these territories. Therefore, even if a person loses their farm, they may also lose access to the food they need to survive. Health is also affected because essential services fail to reach them. The availability of drinking water and water security are also central issues in the region.
These conditions contribute to extreme events turning into disasters, leaving the population without access to food, income, housing, and health services. These are structural vulnerabilities that are not yet fully addressed by policies designed to tackle such challenges in the Amazon.
One of the priorities should be investment in early warning systems. These systems have two dimensions: improving models to anticipate events, despite uncertainties, and preparing the population for potential impacts.
But climate instability also manifests itself in other events. Heavy rains in the Southeast and episodes of low temperatures are examples of this imbalance. When temperatures rise, heat waves can be very intense—not just a slight increase in temperature.
That is why we need to invest in early-warning systems for the Amazon, with special attention to major rivers, water volume, and rainfall.
And beyond environmental alerts and solutions?
Another area of focus is developing social protection mechanisms. Today we have policies such as Bolsa Floresta and Bolsa Família, which help prevent people from going hungry. But in the Amazon, there is an additional challenge: many people are unable to reach the city to receive these benefits, especially during a severe drought.
Policies need to take regional differences into account. It’s also necessary to strengthen municipalities’ capacity to anticipate events, organize distribution systems, and ensure that water reaches the population, preventing communities from remaining in a state of emergency.
What we have seen is that some people are abandoning their territories because they are cut off for months. Unable to travel, they lose access to schools, health services, and even diesel fuel. This does not mean that building roads is the solution. The challenge lies in the great distances and the limited capacity of municipalities to respond to these situations.
There are also independent initiatives by the communities themselves to fill the institutional void. In some cases, people must find solutions on their own: setting up seedling nurseries, adapting their homes, changing their ways of life, or even leaving the area before a major drought strikes.
When they migrate to cities, however, these people can also become more vulnerable. Many lack the resources or are unprepared to enter the urban labor market. Thus, migration can generate new negative impacts.
At the same time, there are important examples of community organization. In Acre, the Organization of Indigenous Peoples of Juruá, in the Upper Juruá region, is working with the Ashaninka to develop a WhatsApp communication system to anticipate risks. The communities share information about river levels and issue alerts when an area begins to dry up, allowing others to prepare for the coming days.
The idea is to improve these tools by linking risk alerts to guidance on what to do and to the institutions that can make decisions. It is also important to bring IPAM initiatives—such as ACI [Indigenous Climate Alert] and SOMAI [Indigenous Amazon Observation and Monitoring System]—closer to Civil Defense and other agencies capable of taking action to prevent risks from turning into disasters.
How have the social impacts of climate change and the adaptation needs of the most vulnerable populations been addressed in international climate negotiations?
This issue is already part of the discussions. There are various initiatives and instruments at the international level. One of them is the Global Goal on Adaptation, under the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change.
The goal is to guide countries’ efforts and establish what needs to be done, taking into account different dimensions of vulnerability and their intersectionalities. This includes women, indigenous peoples, the elderly, children, and people living on the streets or in slums.
There is also a set of indicators designed to assess the scale of what needs to be done, the associated costs, and the measures already implemented. This body of information helps guide countries in their adaptation agenda.
When we look specifically at indigenous peoples and the Amazon, while also considering issues of gender and age, we realize that Brazil is still far behind. The gap between what we need to do and what has actually been accomplished is enormous and continues to widen, while the risks are also growing.
The very purpose of international negotiations is to bridge this gap. To do so, we need to accelerate implementation and expand investments in adaptation strategies, in order to reduce risks in the face of increasing extreme events and climate impacts.
Another important tool is the Loss and Damage Fund. It is especially relevant for the Amazon because it seeks to support populations and regions that bear little responsibility for the destabilization of the Earth’s system, rising temperatures, and greenhouse gas emissions.
The challenge, however, is determining how much money will actually be allocated to the fund and who will have access to these resources. Island nations are on the front lines of these impacts, but the Amazon, indigenous peoples, and traditional communities must also be taken into account.
There is an expectation that we can develop a similar mechanism specifically geared toward the Amazon. The TFFF, which focuses on financing tropical forests, can also serve as a tool to help fund adaptation strategies and reduce the risks faced by Amazonian communities.
Within the Global Adaptation Goal, there is also the LCIPP, the Local Communities and Indigenous Peoples Platform. It establishes specific indicators and criteria to account for the unique characteristics of these groups and help reduce their risks.
How are social tipping points defined? Is there a specific metric or study to identify when a society ceases to be sustainable or reaches a point of no return?
Tipping points are points ofnoreturn. We’ve heard a lot about them from an ecological perspective, especially regarding the forest’s points of no return.
In the case of social tipping points, they can result from different factors—that is, different forces that trigger change. In the context of what we are studying, the IPCC considers climate change to be one of these forces.
Extreme weather events affect a population, a region, or a socioeconomic system and can trigger impacts that destabilize a society, an ecosystem, or a community. This destabilization can occur suddenly and abruptly.
Once triggered, it can create a cascade effect. Let’s consider a major drought in the Amazon. A population lives in relative harmony with the ecosystem but faces natural variations: sometimes they have food, sometimes they don’t; sometimes they have access to healthcare, sometimes they don’t. These fluctuations are part of the territory’s dynamics.
But when a drought lasts for months, the situation can change completely. The population becomes isolated, loses access to food and health care, and faces the loss of biodiversity. This can lead people to abandon the territory.
This is an example of how a tipping point can materialize: a lack of access to health care, for example, can force someone to leave their community and seek treatment in a city. These are disruptions that occur in a cascade effect: one impact leads to another, and it is rarely possible to reverse the process.
The main characteristic of tipping points is precisely their irreversibility. There is also an element of unpredictability in their outcomes and a great difficulty in reversing them once the process begins.
However, many social tipping points are used in the literature to discuss positive transformations. There is a book called *The Tipping Point*, which presents examples of major social changes that began in specific places and spread, becoming difficult to reverse.
One example is the change in attitudes toward smoking indoors. This transformation did not occur simultaneously everywhere in the world. It began in a few centers and gradually spread until it became a widely established practice.
The internet itself and the use of fire are examples of transformations that have profoundly changed society. Today, it is difficult to imagine life without these elements. The use of seat belts can also be understood as a well-established social change.
Therefore, social tipping points occur when a system shifts from one state of equilibrium to another, in a transition that can be disruptive and lead to positive or negative consequences. That is why we distinguish between positive and negative social tipping points.
So, can the pursuit of sustainability, balance, and climate adaptation also be understood as a turning point toward a more sustainable way of life?
Exactly. That is one possibility. Social tipping points do not have to represent only a negative scenario or a situation of collapse. They can also describe positive transformations that lead society toward a more sustainable way of life and, once consolidated, become difficult to reverse.
What issues will be on the agenda at COP31 in Turkey?
I think it’s important to start with an overview of the disasters that are already occurring. We are losing resources and economic and material assets in the world’s largest tropical rainforest. The Amazon is essential for climate stability and for addressing the crisis itself.
The region is seen as a great source of hope because of the climate-regulating services it provides. At the same time, the people on the front lines—precisely those living in areas with lower rates of deforestation, land encroachment, and resource exploitation—are among those most affected by the climate crisis.
These events no longer occur in isolation. A severe drought may be followed by a flood in the next season and then by a fire, or vice versa. These are compound and consecutive events that undermine communities’ ability to respond, even when they manage to organize themselves autonomously.
This situation is exacerbated by the institutional vacuum. It is important to highlight this paradox: the territories that help conserve the forest and regulate the climate are also those whose populations face increasingly intense impacts.
From there, we can draw a connection to social tipping points. There are points of no return and social tipping points that, in some places, can already be observed among Indigenous peoples and traditional populations.
When the impacts become irreversible, problems such as health crises, forced migration, and abandonment of territories in search of medical treatment or basic survival conditions may arise. This means losing access to food, compromising ways of life, and, ultimately, losing one’s culture.
We cannot replicate these conditions on another scale or in a short period of time, even with all available resources. These are issues directly related to climate justice and must be considered in discussions about financing.
We need to unlock the resources earmarked for adaptation in countries of the Global South, including Brazil. It is also essential that all countries strengthen their commitment to reducing emissions, especially the largest emitters.
In this context, the United States’ withdrawal from the Paris Agreement is a cause for concern, as the country continues to emit large quantities of greenhouse gases. China also has high emissions, but managed to significantly reduce them last year.
Brazil, for its part, has shown a positive outlook by reducing deforestation in the Amazon and the Cerrado. These measures help lower emissions and prevent the climate crisis from worsening. But it’s still not enough. We need to be much more ambitious on all these fronts.